Tuesday, December 02, 2008

Blood in the Water: Apple's Class Actions

PHUTATORIUS
It's generally accepted in the tech community, and in the broader population, too, that Apple makes terrific, user-friendly products. So why is it, then, that there are so many consumer class action cases pending against Apple in the courts? The answer is a simple one: one class action attorney took a shot at suing Apple. Apple settled a frivolous claim. Now there's blood in the water, and the sharks are circling.

In December 2003 plaintiffs' attorneys filed a consumer class action suit in against Apple in California state court over the battery life of its early iPods. The lawsuit had no legal basis. All sorts of appliances contain lithium ion batteries. Lithium ion batteries wear out after a certain number of charge cycles, rendering the appliance useless if the battery isn't replaced. Sometimes surgery is required to replace the battery. Apple made no representations that its iPods were immortal, or that they would last longer than they did. The company did supply a limited warranty, and from what I can see, nothing about the iPods' battery life breached its terms. Sure, folks were exasperated that when confronted with this issue, Apple proposed to charge them $100 to replace the battery (or its employeees tried to take advantage of the moment to sell them a new iPod — I myself wrote something pithy to Apple about this some time ago). This was a matter of some controversy for Apple, and it's fair to say it marked the end of the company's iPod Honeymoon.

But the core of the matter is that the class plaintiffs' cause of action against Apple was very weak, but rather than absorb the discovery costs, legal fees, and the ongoing PR hit of litigating the case on the merits (to an uncertain, if nonetheless very likely favorable conclusion), the company elected, in June 2005, to settle the case for approximately $15 million. The court approved payment of $2.7 million in attorney's fees to class counsel.

Since that time, Apple has been inundated with consumer class action lawsuits. Here's an exhausting — if not exhaustive — list of the cases Apple has pending right now (and in the spirit of completeness I've thrown in a few that have been recently dismissed as well):

*Six class complaints (Wimmer v. Apple Computer, Inc., Civ. No. 5:05-4244 (N.D. Cal. Oct. 19, 2005); Moschella v. Apple Computer, Inc., Civ. No. 5:05-4372 (N.D. Cal. filed Oct. 26, 2005); Kahan v. Apple Computer, Inc., Civ. No. 1:05-9251 (S.D.N.Y. filed Oct. 31, 2005); Jennings v. Apple Computer, Inc., Civ. No. 5:05-4520 (N.D. Cal. filed Nov. 4, 2005); Rappel v. Apple Computer, Inc., Civ. No. 3:05-5622 (D.N.J. filed Nov. 23, 2005); Mayo v. Apple Computer, Inc., Civ. No. 3:05-1382 (M.D. La. filed June 6, 2006)), now consolidated under a single multidistrict litigation caption (MDL No. 1754), alleging a design defect in the first generation iPod Nano's LCD screen.

COMMENT: The first generation Nanos were released on September 7, 2005, hard on the heels of the iPod battery settlement. By the end of October Apple was already served with three class action suits over scratched display screens. Coincidence? Hardly. In fact, when you consider the time it takes to evaluate a product, identify its defects, then slap together a coherent class complaint, it wouldn't surprise me if Mr. Wimmer's attorneys didn't get hold of the first Nano ever released — for the sole purpose of beating the hell out of it and then bringing suit. Apple made no promises about the display screen: there are causes for customer dissatisfaction, and there are grounds for lawsuits. With the battery settlement, Apple has allowed class attorneys to blur the distinction.

*Three cases (Leung v. Apple Computer, Inc., Civ. No. 07-4143 (N.D. Cal. filed Aug. 13, 2007); Stiener v. Apple, Inc., Civ. No. 07-04486 (N.D. Cal. filed Aug. 29, 2007); Trujillo v. Apple Computer, Inc., Civ. No. 07-04946 (N.D. Ill. filed Sept. 6, 2007)) complaining that the battery life in Apple's iPhones is too short. Leung voluntarily dismissed his case shortly after filing. Apple recently won summary judgment in Trujillo, as the court found that it made adequate disclosures about its lithium ion batteries on the iPhone's packaging (a lesson no doubt learned from the iPod cases).

COMMENT: These claims are the lousy iPod battery claims all over again, with a different product. Next!

*A class lawsuit (Li v. Apple, Inc., Civ. No. 07-4005 (E.D.N.Y.)) brought on behalf of persons who bought iPhones before Apple reduced their price by $200, to recover what buyers "overpaid."

COMMENT: This is the gold standard of frivolous class action lawsuits. Brush aside for a moment the complaint's several citations to federal laws on price discrimination and underselling — and just imagine living in a society that requires businesses that discount their sales prices to reimburse all their previous customers for the price difference.

*Two class complaints (Smith v. Apple, Inc., Civ. No. 08-AR-1498 (N.D. Ala. filed Aug. 19, 2008); Walters v. Apple Computer, Inc., Civ. No. 4:08-002484 E.D. Ark. filed Sept. 12, 2008)) claiming that Apple's advertising of its G3 iPhones as "twice as fast" for "half the price" was misleading and deceptive.
*Two other 3G class complaints (Sen v. Apple Inc., Civ. No. 1:08-03864 (E.D.N.Y. filed Sept. 22, 2008); Gillis v. Apple Computer, Inc., Civ. No. 08-01835 (S.D. Cal. filed Oct. 8, 2008)), both of which target the adequacy of the 3G service, with the Sen case appending claims relating to "hairline cracks in the iPhones' casing."

COMMENT: The iPhone 3Gs were only released on July 11, and the third-generation lawsuits have come in short order. There's a rhythm emerging here: product is released, purchased, reviewed, broken, and then it becomes the subject of a lawsuit. The fact that attorneys are basing their claims on the puffery in Apple's ad slogans signs as well that it's open season on the folks in Cupertino.

All of the above cases are brought under state and/or federal consumer protection laws, and the substance of the claims is that Apple acted unfairly or deceptively in selling iPods and iPhones that did not comport with the buyers' expectations. The plaintiffs' argue from here that Apple had a duty to disclose the deficiencies in their products (or, as in the "twice as fast" cases, to refrain from exaggerating their merits in promotions). All these claims are patterned after the plaintiffs' theory of relief in the battery litigation.

And I haven't even bulleted the parallel actions that are pending in other jurisdictions, include Canadian class litigation over iPod battery life that Apple settled earlier this year. The Canadian class litigation was filed on June 7, 2005, five days after Apple settled the U.S. litigation on the same issue. Truly a game of Whack-a-Mole here.

Class action attorneys are exploring other claims against Apple, beyond those sounding in the consumer protection laws. These include:

*A product liability class action (Birdsong v. Apple Computer, Inc., Civ. No. 06-02280 (W.D. La. filed Jan 30, 2006)) seeking damages for hearing loss resulting from iPod and earbud use, on design defect and failure to warn theories.

*A class complaint (Holman v. Apple, Inc., Civ. No. 07-05152 (N.D. Cal.)) claiming that Apple's "bricking" of the iPhone — i.e., its exclusive cellular service provider deal with AT&T — violated the Cartwright Act, California's antitrust law.

COMMENT: I'm far from an antitrust law expert, but this seems to me to be another case of class attorneys trying, into the teeth of reason and good sense, to fashion a common geek-complaint about a product into a cause of action. Consumers aren't entitled — even in California — to have McDonald's serve them Pepsi. Absent evidence that Apple and/or AT&T is leveraging monopoly power here, there is no legal claim here. And for that matter, hackers have devised their own workarounds.

*Four class complaints (Slattery v. Apple Computer, Inc., Civ. No. 05-00037 (N.D. Cal. filed Jan. 3, 2005); Tucker v. Apple Computer, Inc., Civ. No. 06-04457 (N.D. Cal. filed July 21, 2006); Black v. Apple, Inc., Civ. No. 07-61395 (S.D. Fla. filed Sept. 28, 2007); Somers v. Apple, Inc., Civ. No. 07-06507 (N.D. Cal. filed Dec. 31, 2007)) brought under the Sherman Act, the Cartwright Act, and other state consumer protection provisions, centered on Apple's iTunes/iPhone product-tying practices. Black has been transferred to the district court in California, and the cases have been consolidated under a single caption. I'm pretty sure the Somers plaintiff is a classmate of mine.

COMMENT: Of the cases I've listed, these are the closest to advancing cogent, viable legal theories, simply because of the iPod's tremendous market share. There is the potential to make monopoly arguments here. And as it happens, the Slattery case was filed five months before Apple settled the iPod battery case — it's a relic of an era when meritorious claims were the order of the day. That three other suits have followed, in pile-on style, is more evidence of Apple's predicament.

It's commonplace by now to compare lawyers to "sharks," and I indulged that cliché at the beginning of this post. In Apple's case, an analogy to piranhas may be more appropriate. The company has literally been swarmed over with junk class action claims — and all because it displayed a willingness to settle a claim it could easily (in my view) have won if it had litigated to the hilt. Now the company can't even change a price point without finding itself haled into court over it, and if (God forbid!) it should release an actual product, trumped-up claims will arrive by the dozens. And if the product is popular, or even iconic, so much the better, from the plaintiffs' perspective, as the prospective class will be even bigger.

If Apple had that first battery case to do over, knowing what it does now, do you suppose it would settle? Eesh.

13 comments:

Meiqing Xu said...

coach outlet store
ralph lauren
louis vuitton handbags
michael kors bags
nfl jerseys
coach outlet store online clearances
coach factory outlet
cheap jordans free shipping
coach outlet
ed hardy
20161223caiyan

dong dong23 said...

christian louboutin sale
ralph lauren polo
uggs pas cher
louis vuitton purses
canada goose outlet
ralph lauren polo
oakley sunglasses wholesale
cheap ugg boots
snapback hats
louis vuitton outlet online
2017.1.16chenlixiang

Mohammed Ahmed said...

JEE Main Result 2018
JEE Main Result 2018 CBSE
IIT JEE Main Result 2018
JEE Main Rank Card 2018 Download
CBSE JEE Main 2018 Result
JEE Main Result 2018 By CBSE
JEE Mains Result 2018 Online
JEE Main Results 2018 Date
GATE 2018 Result Date
GATE 2018 Results
GATE 2018 Score Card Download
GATE 2018 Results
GATE Result 2018
GATE Result 2018 Date & Time
GATE Result 2018 Online
GATE Results 2018 Live
TN HSC Result 2018
TN Plus Two Result 2018
TN Board 12th Result 2018
Tamilnadu HSC Result 2018
TN HSC 12th Class Result 2018
TN HSC Arts, Scinece, Commerce
TN HSC Result 2018 Date
TN HSC Supplementary Result 2018
TN SSLC Result 2018
TN 10th Result 2018
Tamilnadu Board Result 2018
Tamil Nadu SSLC 10th Result 2018
TN SSLC Result 2018
TN SSLC Result 2018 Date
TN SSLC Result 2018 Online
TN SSLC Supplementary Result 2018
AP SSC Results 2018
AP 10th Results 2018
Manabadi SSC Results 2018
Schools9 SSC Results 2018
SSC Results 2018 Andhra Pradesh
AP 10th Results 2018 Date
AP SSC 10th Results 2018 Manabadi
AP SSC Supplementary Results 2018

Mohammed Ahmed said...

ISC Result 2018
ISC 12th Result 2018
CISCE 12th Result 2018
ISC Board Result 2018
ISC Result 2018 Class 12
ISC Result 2018 Date
ISC Result 2018 Class 12
ISC Result 2018 Arts, Science, Commerce
GSEB SSC Result 2018
GSEB 10th Result 2018
Gujarat SSC Result 2018
Gujarat Board 10th Result 2018
GSEB SSC 10th Class Result 2018
GSEB 10th Result 2018 Date
GSEB Result 2018 Class 10
GSEB SSC Purak Pariksha Result 2018
JAC 10th Result 2018
JAC Matric Result 2018
Jharkhand 10th Result 2018
JAC Result 2018 Class 10
JAC Board Result 2018
JAC 10th Result 2018 Date
JAC Board Result 2018
JAC 10th Compartment Result 2018
GSEB HSC Result 2018
GSEB 12th Result 2018
Gujarat HSC Result 2018
Gujarat 12th Class Result 2018
GSEB Result 2018 Class 12
GSEB HSC Science Result 2018
GSEB HSC Commerce Result 2018
GSEB HSC Arts Result 2018
HBSE 10th Result 2018
HBSE Matric Result 2018
HBSE Result 2018 Class 10
Haryana Board 10th Result 2018
Haryana HBSE Result 2018
HBSE 10th Result 2018 Date
HBSE Result 2018 10 Class Date
HBSE 10th Compartment Result 2018

Mohammed Ahmed said...

RBSE Result 2018 Class 10
RBSE 10th Result 2018
Rajasthan 10th Result 2018
Raj Board 10th Result 2018
Rajasthan Board 10th Result 2018
Rajasthan Board 10th Result 2018 Date
RBSE Result 2018 Class 10 Date
RBSE 10th Supplementary Result 2018
BSEB 12th Result 2018
BSEB Intermediate Result 2018
Bihar Board 12th Result 2018
Bihar Intermediate Result 2018
BSEB 12th Class Result 2018
BSEB 12th Commerce Result 2018
BSEB 12th Arts Result 2018
BSEB 12th Science Result 2018
WBCHSE HS Result 2018
WB HS Result 2018
WBCHSE 12th Result 2018
West Bengal Higher Secondary Result 2018
WBCHSE Result 2018 HS
WBCHSE HS Result 2018 Date
WB HS Result 2018 Date & Time
WB Board Result 2018 HS
ICSE 10th Result 2018
ICSE Result 2018 Class 10
CISCE ICSE Result 2018
ICSE Board Result 2018
ICSE Results 2018
ICSE Result 2018 Date
ICSE 10th Class Results 2018 Date
ICSE Result 2018 Class 10 Online
PSEB 10th Result 2018
PSEB Result 2018 Class 10
Punjab 10th Result 2018
Punjab Board Matric Result 2018
PSEB Board Result 2018
PSEB 10th Result 2018 Date
Punjab Board 10th Result 2018 Date
PSEB 10th Compartment Result 2018

Mohammed Ahmed said...

HBSE 12th Result 2018
HBSE Plus Two Result 2018
Haryana Board 12th Result 2018
HBSE Result 2018 Class 12
Haryana Board Result 2018
HBSE 12th Result 2018 Date
HBSE Result 2018 Arts, Science, Commerce
HBSE 12th Compartment Result 2018
CGBSE 10th Result 2018
CGBSE Matric Result 2018
CG Board 10th Result 2018
CG 10th Result 2018
Chhattisgarh 10th Result 2018
CGBSE 10th Result 2018 Date
CGBSE Result 2018 Class 10 Online
CGBSE 10th Supplementary Result 2018
AP EAMCET Results 2018
AP EAMCET Results 2018 Manabadi
AP EAMCET 2018 Results
AP EAMCET Rank Card 2018 Download
Manabadi EAMCET Results 2018
Schools9 EAMCET Results 2018
Eenadu EAMCET Results 2018
Sakshi EAMCET Results 2018 AP
CBSE 12th Result 2018
CBSE Result 2018 Class 12
CBSE Plus Two Result 2018
CBSE Board Result 2018
CBSE 12th Result 2018
CBSE Result 2018 Class 12 Date
CBSE 12th Result 2018 School Wise
CBSE 12th Result 2018 Region Wise
CGBSE 12th Result 2018
CGBSE Result 2018 Class 12
CG Board 12th Result 2018
CG 12th Class Result 2018
Chhattisgarh Board 12th Result 2018
CGBSE 12th Result 2018 Date
CGBSE Result 2018 General & Vocational
CGBSE 12th Supplementary Result 2018

Mohammed Ahmed said...

Odisha 10th Result 2018
Odisha HSC Result 2018
BSE Odisha Result 2018
Odisha Matric Result 2018
Odisha HSC 10th Result 2018
Odisha 10th Result 2018 Date
Odisha HSC 10th Result 2018 Online
Odisha HSC Supplementary Result 2018
Kerala HSE Result 2018
Kerala +2 Result 2018
DHSE Kerala Result 2018
Kerala Plus Two Result 2018
Kerala 12th Result 2018
Kerala Plus Two Result 2018 Date
Kerala DHSE +2 Result 2018
DHSE Plus One Result 2018
MP Board 12th Result 2018
MP Board HSSC Result 2018
MPBSE 12th Class Result 2018
MP Board Result 2018 12th Class
Madhya Pradesh Board 12th Result 2018
MP Board 12th Arts Result 2018
MP Board 12th Science Result 2018
MP Board 12th Commerce Result 2018
Kerala SSLC Result 2018
Kerala 10th Result 2018
SSLC Result 2018 Kerala Board
Kerala SSLC 10th Result 2018
Kerala Board Matric Result 2018
Kerala SSLC Result 2018 Date
Kerala 10th Result 2018 Date
Kerala SSLC SAY Result 2018
HPBOSE 12th Result 2018
HPBOSE Plus Two Result 2018
HP Board 12th Result 2018
HPBOSE Result 2018 Class 12
HP Board +2 Result 2018
HPBOSE 12th Result 2018 Date
HPBOSE 12th Result Arts, Science, Commerce
HPBOSE 12th Compartment Result 2018

Mohammed Ahmed said...

MP Board 10th Result 2018
MP Board HSC Result 2018
MPBSE 10th Result 2018
MPBSE Result 2018 10th HSC
Madhya Pradesh Board 10th Result 2018
MP Board 10th Result 2018 Date
MPBSE 10th Result 2018 Date
MP Board 10th Supplementary Result 2018
UP Board 10th Result 2018
UP Board Highschool Result 2018
UP Highschool Result 2018
UP Board Matric Result 2018
UP Board Result 2018 10th Class
UP Board Result 2018 Date
UP 10th Class Result 2018 Date
UP Highschool Result 2018 Date
WB Madhyamik Result 2018
WB 10th Result 2018
Madhyamik Result 2018 West Bengal
WB Madhyamik Result 2018
WB Madhyamik Result 2018 Date
WB Board 10th Class Result 2018
WBBSE 10th Class Result 2018 Date
Madhyamik Result 2018 Date
UP Board 12th Result 2018
UP Board Intermediate Result 2018
UP Intermediate Result 2018
UP Board Result 2018 12th Class
Uttar Pradesh Board 12th Result 2018
UP Board 12th Result 2018 Date
UP Intermediate Result 2018 Date
UP Board Result 2018 Class 12
CBSE 10th Result 2018
CBSE Result 2018 Class 10
CBSE Results 2018
CBSE Result 2018 Region Wise
CBSE 10th Result 2018 School Wise
CBSE Result 2018 Class 10 Date
CBSE 10th Result 2018 Region Wise
CBSE 10th Compartment Result 2018

Mohammed Ahmed said...

PUC Result 2018 Karnataka
Karnataka 2nd PUC Result 2018
2nd PUC Result 2018
Karnataka PUC Result 2018 Exam
Karnataka PUC 2nd Year Result 2018
2nd PUC Result 2018 Date
PUC Result 2018 Karnataka Board
Karnataka PUC Supplementary Result 2018
SSC Result 2018 Maharashtra
Maharashtra 10th Result 2018
Maharashtra Board Result 2018
Maharashtra 10th Class Board Result 2018
SSC 10th Result 2018 Maharashtra Board
SSC Result 2018 Maharashtra Board Date & Time
Maharashtra Board 10th Result 2018 Date
Maharashtra SSC 10th Supplementary Result 2018
Maharashtra Board HSC Result 2018
Maharashtra 12th Result
Maharashtra Board Result 2018
Maharashtra HSC 12th Result 2018
HSC 12th Result 2018 Maharashtra Board
HSC Result 2018 Maharashtra Board Date & Time
Maharashtra Board Result 2018 Date
Maharashtra Board 12th Class Result 2018
Bihar Board 10th Result 2018
Bihar Board Matric Result 2018
BSEB 10th Result 2018
BSEB Matric Result 2018
Bihar Board Result 2018 10th Class
Bihar Board 10th Result 2018 Date
Bihar Board Matric Result 2018 Date
Bihar Board 10th Compartment Result 2018
Karnataka SSLC Result 2018
Karnataka 10th Result 2018
Karnataka SSLC 10th Result 2018
SSLC Result 2018 Karnataka
SSLC 10th Result 2018 Karnataka Board
Karnataka SSLC Result 2018 Date
Karnataka Board 10th Result 2018 Date
Karnataka SSLC Supplementary Result 2018

Mohammed Ahmed said...

AP Inter Results 2018
AP Intermediate Results 2018
AP Inter 2nd Year Results 2018
AP Inter 1st Year Results 2018
AP Inter Results 2018 Manabadi
AP Inter 1st Year Results 2018 Schools9
AP Inter 2nd Year Results 2018 Sakshi
AP Inter Supplementary Results 2018
TS Intermediate Results 2018
TS Inter Results 2018
TS Inter 1st Year Results 2018
TS Inter 2nd Year Results 2018
TS Inter Results 2018 Manabadi
TS Inter 1st Year Results 2018 Schools9
TS Inter 2nd Year Results 2018 Sakshi
TS Inter Results 2018 Eenadu, Prathiba
Telangana 10th Results 2018
TS 10th Results 2018
Telangana SSC Results 2018
Manabadi SSC Results 2018
TS SSC Results 2018
TS SSC Results 2018 Date
TS 10th Results 2018 Sakshi
TS SSC Supplementary Results 2018
NEET Result 2018
NEET PG Result 2018
NEET UG Result 2018
NEET 2018 Results
NEET 2018 Exam Result
NEET Result 2018 Date
NEET 2018 Result Online
NEET 2018 Result Name Wise
TS EAMCET Results 2018
Telangana EAMCET Results 2018
TS EAMCET Rank Card 2018
TS EAMCET Results 2018 Manabadi
Schools9 TS EAMCET Result 2018
Telangana EAMCET Results 2018 Eenadu
TS EAMCET Results 2018 Online
EAMCET Results 2018 TS Date

Mohammed Ahmed said...

Eid Mubarak Images 2018
Eid Mubarak 2018
Eid Mubarak Quotes 2018
Eid Mubarak Wallpapers 2018
Eid Mubarak Wishes 2018
Assam HSLC Result 2018
Assam 10th Result 2018
Assam Board Result 2018
SEBA HSLC Result 2018
SEBA 10th HSLC Result 2018
Assam HSLC Result 2018 Date
AHM 10th Result 2018 Date
Assam HSLC Compartment Result 2018
Meghalaya Election Results 2018
Meghalaya Election 2018 Date
Meghalaya Election 2018 Opinion Poll
Meghalaya Election Exit Polls 2018
Meghalaya Election 2018 Live Updates
Karnataka Election Results 2018
Karnataka Election 2018 Date
Karnataka Election 2018 Opinion Poll
Karnataka Election Exit Poll 2018
Karnataka Election 2018 Live Updates

Mohammed Ahmed said...

HPBOSE 10th Result 2018
HPBOSE Matric Result 2018
HP Board 10th Result 2018
HP Matric Result 2018
HPBOSE Result 2018 10th Class
HPBOSE Result 2018 Class 10
HPBOSE Matric 10th Result 2018
HPBOSE Result 2018
MP Election Results 2018
MP Election 2018 Date
MP Election 2018 Opinion Poll
MP Election 2018 Exit Poll
MP Election 2018 Live Updates
Rajasthan Election Results 2018
Rajasthan Election 2018 Date
Rajasthan Election 2018 Opinion Poll
Rajasthan Election 2018 Exit Poll
Rajasthan Election 2018 Live Updates

Mohammed Ahmed said...

Chhattisgarh Election Results 2018
Chhattisgarh Election 2018 Date
Chhattisgarh Election 2018 Opinion Poll
Chhattisgarh Election 2018 Exit Poll
Chhattisgarh Election 2018 Live Updates
Happy New Year 2019
Happy New Year 2019 Images
Happy New Year wallpapers 2019
Happy New Year 2019 Quotes
Happy New Year 2019 Messages
Happy New Year 2019 Status
Happy New Year 2019 Photos
Happy New Year 2019 Pic Download
Tripura Election Results 2018
Tripura Election 2018 Date
Tripura Election 2018 Opinion Poll
Tripura Election Exit Polls 2018
Tripura Election 2018 Live Updates

Post a Comment